Papa Murphy’s Secret Menu: 10 Pizza Hacks & How to Order
PAPA MURPHY’S USA • SECRET MENU
Papa Murphy’s Secret Menu: 10 Pizza Hacks & How to Order
Papa Murphy’s is built for take-and-bake customization. The strongest secret-menu-style orders use Half & Half pizzas, Create Your Own builds, dairy-free cheese, crustless keto trays, custom calzones, Mini Murph options, and Create Your Own salads.
Menu choices, crusts, toppings, sauces, and prices vary by store. Start with the official build shown by your selected location, then make one or two clear changes at a time.
10
practical hacks
Half + Half
two recipes in one pizza
5
toppings on many custom builds
Take & Bake
finish it at home
Papa Murphy’s custom orders work best when you use the official format instead of asking for a hidden-name pizza. The menu already supports Half & Half builds, dairy-free cheese, crustless keto trays, custom calzones, and custom salads, which gives you plenty of room to create something different without leaving the normal ordering system.
Does Papa Murphy’s Have a Secret Menu?
Papa Murphy’s does not advertise a separate nationwide hidden-menu board. Its regular ordering system is flexible enough to function like one. Create Your Own pizzas let you select size, crust, and toppings, while Half & Half, dairy-free, crustless keto, calzone, Mini Murph, and salad formats create several distinct paths for custom orders.
For standard pizza categories and prices, use the fixed Papa Murphy’s menu. Deal-focused coverage belongs on the fixed Papa Murphy’s happy hour page, so this article stays focused on everyday customization.
For other pizza-chain custom orders, compare the Pizza Hut secret menu and the Domino’s secret menu. Papa Murphy’s differs because the pizza is assembled in-store and baked at home.
Papa Murphy’s Secret Menu: 10 Hacks at a Glance
The first six hacks focus on pizza formats, dairy-free cheese, and keto-friendly crustless builds. The next three cover calzones and salads. The last hack uses the take-and-bake model itself to help you get the texture you prefer while staying inside the baking directions.
| Hack | Start with | Change | Why it works |
|---|---|---|---|
| Half & Half Mashup | Create Your Own Half & Half | Combine two specialty recipes or custom halves | Official split-pizza format |
| Five-Topping Build | Create Your Own | Choose size, crust, and up to 5 toppings | Official custom-pizza format |
| Dairy-Free Custom Pizza | Dairy-Free Cheese Create Your Own | Use Violife dairy-free cheese + toppings | Official dairy-free option |
| Dairy-Free Mini Murph | Mini Murph | Choose dairy-free cheese where offered | Official kid-size option |
| Crustless Keto Build | Create Your Own Crustless | Choose sauce or no sauce + keto-friendly toppings | Official keto-friendly format |
| Keto Sauce Swap | Cowboy or other crustless recipe | Swap red sauce for Creamy Garlic or Olive Oil & Garlic | Official keto-friendly instruction |
| Custom Calzone | Create Your Own Calzone | Choose sauce, up to 4 toppings, and dip | Official calzone format |
| Dairy-Free Calzone | Dairy-Free Cheese Create Your Own Calzone | Use dairy-free cheese + custom toppings | Official dairy-free calzone |
| Custom Salad | Create Your Own Salad | Choose greens + up to 5 toppings | Official custom salad |
| Bake-Time Texture Hack | Any take-and-bake pizza | Follow store instructions and adjust home bake within directions | Uses take-and-bake format |
The easiest orders are the ones the store already knows how to assemble. Half & Half and Create Your Own formats give you the most control without requiring a custom recipe explanation. For wider price context, see the cheapest pizza chains in the USA page.
6 Pizza Hacks
1. Build a Half & Half Mashup
Papa Murphy’s officially offers Create Your Own Half & Half at participating stores. You can choose a size and combine two specialty recipes, or create a split combination with toppings supported by the store. The Half & Half price follows the higher-priced side, so compare the finished cart rather than assuming the two halves are averaged.
This is useful when two people want different styles but do not need two full pizzas. One side can stay meat-heavy while the other leans vegetable-forward, or one side can use a familiar specialty recipe while the other side becomes the custom half. For another pizza-chain split strategy, see the Marco’s Pizza secret menu.
2. Build a Five-Topping Create Your Own Pizza
The standard Create Your Own format lets you choose the pizza size, crust, and up to five toppings, with the exact charge determined by the store and topping count. That is the cleanest starting point when you want a specific combination that is not already a specialty recipe.
Start with the ingredients that matter most and stop before the pizza becomes overloaded. Because Papa Murphy’s is take-and-bake, a balanced topping distribution also helps the pizza bake more evenly at home. If several toppings duplicate an existing specialty pizza, compare that recipe before paying for a custom build.
3. Make a Dairy-Free Create Your Own Pizza
Papa Murphy’s offers Dairy-Free Cheese Create Your Own using Violife mozzarella-style shreds. The format supports a custom pizza with dairy-free cheese and up to five toppings at participating stores. This is more reliable than ordering a regular pizza and asking employees to improvise a cheese substitute.
The dairy-free cheese option does not make the entire restaurant dairy-free. Papa Murphy’s states that dairy-free items are prepared in shared kitchen areas with products containing dairy. Choose toppings based on the selected store’s ingredient information if an allergy is involved.
4. Use Dairy-Free Cheese on a Mini Murph
Papa Murphy’s also promotes dairy-free cheese for the Mini Murph pizza kit. This kid-size make-your-own format can be a useful smaller order when you want the dairy-free cheese option without buying a full-size custom pizza. Pepperoni may also be available as part of the kit.
The Mini Murph is less about a hidden recipe and more about format control. It keeps the portion smaller and lets the pizza be assembled at home. If a family is ordering several different pizza styles, one Mini Murph can prevent a dietary preference from forcing a change to the entire group order.
5. Build a Crustless Keto-Friendly Pizza
Create Your Own Crustless lets you choose a sauce, or no sauce, and add up to five toppings. Papa Murphy’s marks keto-friendly toppings with a KF label, which makes the builder easier to use when carbohydrate control is the goal. The pizza is baked in a tray rather than on a traditional crust.
Use the keto-friendly markers rather than assuming every topping fits the same nutrition target. Cheese, meats, vegetables, and sauces can change the finished macros substantially. The official builder is the safest place to see which options Papa Murphy’s treats as keto-friendly.
6. Swap the Sauce on a Keto-Friendly Specialty
Papa Murphy’s crustless specialty pages give a specific keto-friendly sauce adjustment for recipes such as Cowboy and Papa’s All Meat. The menu instructs customers to replace Traditional Red Sauce with Creamy Garlic or Olive Oil & Garlic for the keto-friendly version.
That makes the sauce swap one of the most clearly documented secret-menu-style modifications on the site. Keep the rest of the recipe standard if you want a predictable result, or use Create Your Own Crustless if you need more control over toppings. For another pizza customization comparison, the Papa John’s secret menu uses a more traditional baked-for-you model.
4 Calzone, Salad, and Take-and-Bake Hacks
7. Build a Create Your Own Calzone
Papa Murphy’s Create Your Own Calzone lets you choose the sauce and up to four toppings, with topping charges determined by the store. It also includes a choice of dipping sauce cup. This is a useful way to turn familiar pizza ingredients into an individual folded format without buying a full pizza.
Keep the filling combination focused because a calzone has less room than a large pizza. One meat, one or two vegetables, and cheese can be easier to eat and bake than a four-topping mix built entirely around heavy ingredients. Check the dipping sauce choice before adding an extra cup separately.
8. Build a Dairy-Free Create Your Own Calzone
Papa Murphy’s also lists a Dairy-Free Cheese Create Your Own Calzone. The ordering logic mirrors the standard custom calzone: choose the sauce, select up to four toppings, and choose a dipping sauce, but use the dairy-free cheese option supported by the store.
This is useful when one person in a group wants a dairy-free cheese format while everyone else orders regular pizza. It keeps the custom item separate and avoids changing the full group order. Shared-kitchen cautions still apply for allergy-related needs.
9. Make a Five-Topping Create Your Own Salad
The Create Your Own Salad format lets you choose the greens and add up to five toppings, with dressing included. It is a practical side-order hack when pizza is the main meal but someone wants a different topping balance or a lighter companion item.
Use pizza toppings that also make sense cold, such as vegetables or selected proteins shown by the store. Because the salad uses a separate format, it can also help a group share fewer pizza toppings while still getting the ingredients someone wants.
10. Use the Take-and-Bake Format to Control Texture
Papa Murphy’s pizza is sold unbaked, so the final texture happens in your oven. Follow the store’s baking directions first, including any refrigeration instructions. Papa Murphy’s says refrigerated pizza should be baked within 24 hours and brought out before baking so the crust can rise.
Within those directions, watch the crust and cheese near the end of the bake rather than relying only on the clock. Ovens vary, so visual doneness can matter. The goal is not to ignore the instructions, but to use the take-and-bake format to stop when the pizza reaches the texture you prefer.
How to Order Papa Murphy’s Secret-Menu Hacks
Papa Murphy’s custom orders are easiest when you choose the format first. A Half & Half pizza, dairy-free pizza, crustless tray, calzone, Mini Murph, and salad all have different ingredient limits, so deciding the format before the toppings prevents confusion.
- Select the Papa Murphy’s store before choosing a build because item availability differs by location.
- Choose the format first: full pizza, Half & Half, dairy-free, crustless, calzone, Mini Murph, or salad.
- Pick the size and crust before adding toppings on a standard Create Your Own pizza.
- Keep toppings within the limits shown by the selected item so the build stays inside the store’s ordering system.
- For crustless keto orders, use the keto-friendly topping markers and the sauce options shown by Papa Murphy’s.
- Review the cart before paying because toppings, premium formats, dairy-free cheese, and store pricing can change the total.
For the official custom-pizza controls, use Papa Murphy’s Create Your Own menu. If you want another pizza-chain ordering comparison, the Pizza Hut secret menu uses a similar base-first approach but bakes the pizza in the restaurant.
Prices and Availability
Papa Murphy’s prices are store-specific. Pizza size, crust, topping count, dairy-free cheese, calzone ingredients, and local promotions can all change the finished total. Half & Half pricing can also follow the higher-priced half, which matters when one side uses a more expensive specialty recipe.
Use the fixed Papa Murphy’s menu with prices as the planning reference on this site, then choose the store you intend to use before checkout. The selected store is also the final source for crustless, dairy-free, Mini Murph, calzone, and salad participation.
For lower-cost pizza comparisons, use the best fast-food meals under $10 page and the cheapest-pizza roundup. For more restaurant-specific custom orders, browse the Secret Menus category.
Nutrition and Allergen Notes
Crust, sauce, cheese, dairy-free cheese, meats, vegetables, and dipping sauces all change the nutrition profile. A crustless tray is not nutritionally equivalent to a standard pizza, and a dairy-free cheese pizza can still contain other ingredients that matter for a specific diet.
Papa Murphy’s official nutrition and allergen information says its lifestyle-friendly options include Udi’s certified gluten-free crust, Violife dairy-free cheese, and crustless keto-friendly pizzas. The company also notes that gluten-free crust and dairy-free cheese are handled in shared kitchen areas.
Anyone with a serious allergy should review the exact product and speak with the selected store. A menu substitution can change an ingredient without removing cross-contact risk. For another pizza-chain comparison, the Domino’s secret menu should be treated as a separate kitchen and allergen system.
Frequently Asked Questions
Does Papa Murphy’s have a real secret menu?
Papa Murphy’s does not advertise a separate nationwide hidden-menu board. Its practical secret menu comes from official customization formats such as Half & Half, Create Your Own, dairy-free cheese, crustless keto, calzones, and salads.
Can I order a Half & Half pizza at Papa Murphy’s?
Yes. Participating stores list Create Your Own Half & Half, which can combine two specialty recipes or custom halves. The price follows the higher-priced side.
How many toppings can I add to a Papa Murphy’s Create Your Own pizza?
Papa Murphy’s lists up to five toppings on many Create Your Own pizzas, with an added charge per topping depending on the store.
Does Papa Murphy’s have dairy-free cheese?
Yes. Papa Murphy’s offers Violife dairy-free mozzarella-style shreds on supported pizzas and other selected formats.
Can I get dairy-free cheese on a Mini Murph?
Papa Murphy’s says dairy-free cheese is available for the Mini Murph pizza kit at participating locations, including a pepperoni option where offered.
Does Papa Murphy’s have crustless keto pizza?
Yes. The Create Your Own Crustless format lets you choose sauce or no sauce and add keto-friendly toppings marked by Papa Murphy’s.
What sauce should I use for a keto-friendly Cowboy crustless pizza?
Papa Murphy’s instructs customers to replace Traditional Red Sauce with Creamy Garlic or Olive Oil & Garlic for the keto-friendly version.
Can I build my own Papa Murphy’s calzone?
Yes. Create Your Own Calzone lets you choose sauce, up to four toppings, and a dipping sauce cup.
Can I build my own salad at Papa Murphy’s?
Yes. Participating stores list Create Your Own Salad with a greens choice, up to five toppings, and dressing.
How long can an unbaked Papa Murphy’s pizza stay refrigerated?
Papa Murphy’s says unbaked pizza should be baked within 24 hours of purchase and removed from the refrigerator before baking so the crust can rise.
Bottom Line
The Papa Murphy’s secret menu is really a customization playbook. Half & Half pizzas, five-topping builds, dairy-free cheese, Mini Murph kits, crustless keto trays, documented sauce swaps, custom calzones, salads, and the take-and-bake format all provide ways to change the order without relying on a hidden-name recipe.
Start with the format, keep the ingredient list within the official builder, and check the selected store before paying. For more pizza customization ideas, compare Pizza Hut, Domino’s, Marco’s Pizza, or browse the Secret Menus archive.